Skip to content

What is a contra-charge or back-charge in construction?

A contra-charge, also called a back-charge, is a deduction your main contractor makes from your payment for a cost it says you caused.

Updated: . By Jack Butler-Kettle, Construction Claims Consultant.

The answer

Common ones are damage, cleaning, delay, attendances not provided, defects put right by someone else and plant hire. The standard forms do not use the term. It is set-off by another name: a sum your main contractor says you owe, taken out of what it owes you. Three things decide whether it sticks. First, your subcontract must allow the deduction, and many subcontracts widen that right well beyond the standard form. Second, the deduction must come through the payment notices, under section 111 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996. A contra-charge in a Pay Less Notice, with a sum and a basis, is procedurally sound. One that first appears in a final account assessment with neither is not. Third, the sum must be backed by evidence, just as a claim would be. That means what happened, when, who recorded it, what it cost and how the figure was worked out. So when a contra-charge lands, test it on all three. The one most often dropped is the charge raised months after the event, with no record made at the time and a round figure.

Example

Illustrative example. The scenario and figures are invented.

The facts

A main contractor deducts £8,500 from a subcontractor's account for damage to screed, block C. The subcontractor tests the charge three ways: on the evidence, on the contract and on the procedure.

What happens

  1. The subcontractor asks for the date and the site record of the damage. It also asks for the notice given at the time, the repair invoice and the reason it is being blamed.
  2. If the record shows the damage on a day the subcontractor was not on site, the charge fails on evidence.
  3. If the subcontract does not allow set-off for that kind of cost, the charge fails on the contract.
  4. If the deduction never appeared in a Pay Less Notice for the cycle it was taken in, the charge fails on procedure.

The outcome

The £8,500 stands or falls on three tests: the evidence of the damage, the subcontract's set-off terms and the notice for that cycle.

Our Contra-Charge Claim service answers a contra-charge schedule line by line on those three tests.

Sources

  1. Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, s 111 (Requirement to pay notified sum). legislation.gov.uk.